Blog

Domain namesWebsite management

Your domain name is yours. Make sure it actually is.

Your domain name is a business asset, not something your web developer should hold hostage. Here's why ownership matters, how to check who's in control, and how to avoid a very expensive headache.

PublishedNovember 6, 2026
Reading time8 minutes

A hand holds a yellow key beside a padlock on a blue background.

I recently spent a lovely afternoon dealing with a domain transfer that should have been a pretty straightforward process. Naturally, it was not.

A client had parted ways with his previous web company, but for some reason, that company still had his domain name registered in their own account. They were perfectly willing to transfer it over, which was great, but I couldn’t help wondering why they had registered it under their account in the first place. Or why transferring it back wasn’t part of their offboarding process.

Anyway, after some back and forth and a particularly delightful phone call with GoDaddy support, we figured out what needed to happen. But the whole thing reminded me of something I wish more business owners knew:

Your domain name should be registered in an account that you control. Not your web developer’s, not your marketing agency’s, and definitely not some account belonging to a company you stopped working with six months ago.

Let me explain why.

Think of your domain name like the title to your car

Let’s say you buy a car. You pick it out, pay for it, insure it, and drive it around every day. You got your lil tree hanging from the mirror in your favorite scent. It’s your car.

But when you bought it, the dealership decided to put the title in their own name. They tell you it’s just easier that way, and don’t worry, they’ll take care of everything.

That might seem fine until you decide you want to sell the car, trade it in, or take it somewhere else. Suddenly, you have to call the dealership and ask them to transfer the title over to you.

What if they’re no longer in business? What if they don’t answer? What if they decide you owe them money before they’ll cooperate? What if they just say “nah, frigg off”?

Now you’ve got a problem that never needed to exist.

Your domain name works a little differently from a car title, legally speaking. You register the right to use a domain name for a period of time rather than purchasing it outright forever. But the point is the same.

You should be the one holding the keys to something your business depends on.

Your website can be redesigned. Your hosting can be changed. You can fire your developer (even me, although I’d prefer you didn’t pls).

But your domain name is tied to your business identity, and potentially years of marketing, search engine visibility, customer recognition, and email communication.

Losing control of that can be a much bigger problem than having to find somebody new to maintain your website.

“But my web developer handles all that stuff!”

Great! That’s literally part of the job.

I regularly help clients register domains, configure DNS records, connect hosting, set up email authentication, and manage all the other fun little things that happen behind the scenes.

And I completely understand why someone running a restaurant, dental office, or construction company wouldn’t want to deal with any of it.

You shouldn’t have to become a domain management expert just because you need a website.

But there’s an important difference between having someone manage something for you and having someone control it for you.

Think about your accountant. You might give them access to your financial records so they can do your taxes, but you wouldn’t open all your bank accounts in their name just to make their job easier.

Same idea.

Most domain registrars offer ways to give someone else access to manage your domain without handing over your account credentials or putting the registration in their name.

This is called delegated access, or something similar depending on the registrar.

It lets your developer handle the technical stuff while you remain in control of the account.

There are sometimes limitations to what delegated users can do. I learned that one the annoying way during this particular transfer, when GoDaddy gave me a completely unhelpful error message rather than just telling me I needed the actual account owner to accept it.

Twenty-five minutes on the phone to find out something that could have been explained in one sentence. Love that for meeeeee.

But even with those limitations, it’s a much better arrangement than having your domain sitting in somebody else’s account indefinitely.

What happens when you don’t control your domain?

Sometimes, absolutely nothing.

Your web company handles the renewals, everything works, and everybody’s happy.

Until something changes.

Maybe you decide to hire a new developer. Maybe your agency closes. Maybe the person who originally registered your domain disappears off the face of the earth.

Or maybe you discover that your domain expired because somebody forgot to renew it, and all the renewal notices were going to an email address you don’t have access to.

Depending on the situation, you could end up dealing with:

  • Website downtime. If your domain expires or its DNS settings get messed up, customers may not be able to reach your website.
  • Email problems. If you use an email address associated with your domain, DNS changes or expiration can affect that too.
  • Delayed website migrations. Moving a website to another host doesn’t always require transferring the domain, but you’ll generally need someone with the appropriate access to update its DNS settings.
  • A complicated separation from your previous provider. Even if everyone is cooperating, transferring account ownership can involve verification, approvals, and waiting periods.
  • Potentially losing the domain entirely. If a registration expires and isn’t recovered in time, it can eventually become available for someone else to register.

And if the relationship with your previous provider ended badly? Well, now you’re relying on someone you don’t particularly want to deal with to help you recover control of a critical piece of your business.

Sounds fun, right?

How to make sure your domain is actually yours

Luckily, this is pretty easy to prevent. You don’t need to learn how DNS works or memorize a bunch of technical terminology. You just need to make sure a few things are set up correctly.

1. Register the domain yourself

When you’re starting a new website, create your own account with a domain registrar and register the domain there.

Use an email address you control, make sure your business or your name is listed as the registrant, and keep your login credentials somewhere safe.

If you’re not sure which registrar to use, ask your developer for a recommendation. They can walk you through it.

And if you already have a domain registered through your web company, ask them who the listed registrant is and whether the domain can be moved into your own account.

2. Give your developer access without giving up control

Once your account is set up, invite your developer to manage the domain using whatever access-sharing features the registrar provides.

They can take care of DNS settings, connect your website to its hosting, configure email records, and handle other technical tasks as their permissions allow.

You still control the account.

Everybody wins.

3. Turn on auto-renewal

Seriously. Just turn it on.

Domains are generally renewed annually, although you can often register them for multiple years at a time.

Set up automatic renewal, keep your payment information current, and make sure renewal notifications go to an email address you actually check.

I’d also recommend enabling two-factor authentication to protect your registrar account.

4. Know where your domain is registered

You don’t need to log in and stare at your DNS records every week. Please don’t. Go do something fun.

But you should at least know which company your domain is registered through and how to access the account.

If you have no idea, ICANN has a domain lookup tool that can help you identify your registrar.

5. Make domain access part of your off-boarding process

If you’re leaving a web agency or switching developers, make sure domain access is addressed before you part ways.

Confirm who controls the registrar account, who is responsible for renewals, and whether any permissions need to be transferred or removed.

Ideally, this should all be documented from the beginning, but if it wasn’t, now’s a good time to sort it out.

Your developer should make your life easier, not hold your website hostage

I don’t think every company that registers domains on behalf of its clients is doing something shady. Some offer fully managed services, and sometimes it’s simply how their processes have always worked.

But I do think business owners deserve to understand where their domain is registered, who controls it, and what happens if they decide to leave.

A good developer should be able to explain those things without making you feel stupid for asking.

At Channel 37 Online, I want my clients to have control over the things they’ve paid for. I’ll happily take care of all the scary technical nonsense, but you shouldn’t have to track me down someday just to make a change to your own domain.

Your domain is part of your business. Treat it that way.

And if reading this has made you realize you have absolutely no idea where your domain is registered or who has access to it, that’s something we can figure out.

Preferably without spending our lunch break on the phone with GoDaddy.

More where that came from.

Get new articles and useful website advice delivered straight to your inbox.

Almost there! Check your inbox to confirm your subscription. If you’re already subscribed, you’re all set.

Keep me in the loop! I'd like to receive website tips, WordPress news, new blog posts, and occasional updates from Channel 37 Online. I can unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy.

Related reading

Keep em comin'.

Black cat in front of computer screen looking back
CH / 37
NOTES FROM THE DEBUGGING DEPARTMENT
News

Same Signal. New Frequency.

New look, same Channel 37 Online. A behind-the-scenes look at my website rebuild, what's changed, and what's next for the business. With some assistance from two kittens.

Oct 26, 2026 Read article

Still fighting your website?

Okay, now let's talk about your website.

You've seen the advice. Now get the hands-on help to put it into practice.

What's going on with your website?

Have a project in mind, something that needs fixing, or just a question? Share a few details below to get the conversation started.


Your message is on its way, thanks!

We use your details to respond to your inquiry, as explained in our Privacy Policy. Newsletter signup is optional and separate from your inquiry. Select the checkbox only if you want to subscribe; new subscribers must confirm by email.

Menu

This website uses cookies

We use necessary technologies for security, cookie choices, and shopping. With your permission, Google Analytics helps us understand visits and store interactions. You can reject optional cookies or change your choice at any time through Cookie Preferences. Privacy Policy Cookie Policy